|
Post by Dee on Nov 2, 2010 8:37:30 GMT
Nice one Caz Yeah it was particularly funny with Jay Kay, truth hurts eh Cheryl ;D The right ones defiinately went although I don't think Katie will be with us much longer and where were her tears??
|
|
|
Post by joyce on Nov 6, 2010 17:45:48 GMT
Here is tonights song list One Direction – Kids In America by Kim Wilde Katie Waissel – Don’t Speak by No Doubt Cher Lloyd – Empire State of Mind by Jay-Z and Alicia Keys Wagner – Mash up of Viva Las Vegas and Wonder Of You by Elvis Treyc Cohen – I Don’t Want to Miss a Thing by Aerosmith Mary Byrne – There You’ll Be by Faith Hill Aiden Grimshaw – Nothing Compares To You by Prince Rebecca Ferguson – Make You Feel My Love by Bob Dylan Matt Cardle – First Time Ever I Saw Your Face by Roberta Flack Paije Richardson – Mash up of I’m A Believer by The Monkees and Hey Ya! by Outkast
|
|
|
Post by kim on Nov 6, 2010 18:21:37 GMT
Looking forward to Matt, Aiden and Paige - not looking forward to Cher - why are they letting her rap again??
|
|
|
Post by joyce on Nov 6, 2010 18:40:03 GMT
Me too Kim, But I love Mary and Rebecca's song esp Mary's, I was hopeing Matt would sing Rebecca's sometime in the show x
|
|
|
Post by kim on Nov 6, 2010 19:44:01 GMT
Rumours are it's a double elimination for the next fortnight - but I suppose that all depends who's in danger
|
|
|
Post by kim on Nov 6, 2010 21:59:02 GMT
Dermot didn't mention a double elimination, so it must have just been a rumour - shame there are two or three I wouldn't be sorry to see the back of this week Cher - As I thought, if she raps she's rubbish, it all comes across as very contrived. Surprised they put her on first, she must have had high votes in previous weeks 4/10 Mary - Definitely her worst week, she sounded off key throughout, it took me nearly to the end of the song to recognise what she was actually singing. 3/10 Katie - More rubbish - she deserves to go on that performance, I can't see her not being in the bottom two this week 2/10 Aiden - Not my favourite performance of his (I think anyone who sings this will never better Sinead O'Connor), but I still find him mesmerising 6/10 Paige- Liked the Monkees song, but it lost it's way with Hey Ya. Think he'll be safe this week though, but when are they going to give him a Luther Vandross, Teddy Pendergrast or Alexander O'Neil song - they would be perfect for his voice. 7/10 Rebecca - Fantastic, I really like her voice and thought tonight was one of her best. 9/10 Wagner - Getting a bit bored of Wagner now, think he'll survive this week though 3/10 Matt - Oh wow!! I had goosebumps on top of goosebumps, his voice is fantastic and the emotion he brings gives me shivers - I don't know why they don't just crown him the winner now 10/10 Treyc - Her voice is ok, but I find her very boring - not helped by the Aerosmith song - what is Cheryl giving her such odd songs for? 5/10 One Direction - Ok, not my favourite performance of theirs though. 6/10 Favourites: Matt and Rebecca Bottom two: Mary and Katie - Katie will go
|
|
|
Post by joyce on Nov 6, 2010 22:22:19 GMT
Cher - Thought she was very flat, the rap bit was bad, and the singing she totally killed a clasic Alicia Keys Mary - Definitely her worst week, One of my fav songs ruined Katie - Another bad performance Aiden - Thought this was his best week since Mad World, And thought it was up there with the original by Prince, but agree not the emotion of Sinead. Paige- I enjoyed him tonight he has a great voice Rebecca - Fantastic, Great song choice too Wagner -No comment other than a waste of airtime Matt - I just love this guy tonight he had me in tears, I was literally shaking never felt like this since I was a kid with the Beatles lol Treyc - Best performance from her, But she is too shouty One Direction - They are cute kids, they were ok, but they deff mime in parts when the backing takes over Favourites: Matt and Rebecca I think they want Mary on the tour, so Bottom Treyc and Katie - dont think Katie will survive another sing off so Katie to go
|
|
|
Post by Dee on Nov 6, 2010 23:29:56 GMT
Cher - Ok performance but nothing special
Mary - Oh dear, terrible, she needs to go now
Katie - predictable song choice that she didn't do justice.
Aiden - Fab, my favourite performance of his so far, he definately looked more confident. The competition started with Aiden tonight, all those before him may as well leave now. (except Wagner, the only one that deserves to go who sang after him)
Paige - Great & fun but I also thought he would sing a Luther/Alexander O neill song that suited his voice more. He did good with what he was given and he is so likeable, I couldn't stop smiling through his performance.
Rebecca - Excellent, I love that song and it so suited her voice.
Wagner - time to go now please.
Matt - OMG, back on form and the clear winner, I absolutely love his voice, awesome!!
TreyC - Sang a difficult song brilliantly but still forgettable performance.
One Direction - Glad that they didn't sing the obvious back street boys or new kids on the block, good performance but not my favourite.
Favourits: Matt & Rebecca, they were leagues ahead of everyone else tonight.
Bottom Two - Mary & Katie - katie to go. I would prefer Mary to go tbh as I prefer Katies voice more but that's not gonna happen. (Wagner should be there but I am not including him anymore, it will just be a bonus if he goes)
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Nov 7, 2010 13:10:28 GMT
Cher - I wasn't that keen on last nights performance. Mary - Definitely Mary's worst week. Her vocals were so off key. I don't know what was the matter with her last night. Katie - Another performance from her that was just ok. Definitely time for her to go. Aiden - Another brilliant performance from him. Up there with Mad world for being his best. Paije - I thought he gave a good performance. His best to date. Rebecca - Another fab performance from her. Wagner - The second part of the song was quite good for him, I thought. Matt - My eyes were full of tears yet again when he sang this. Just amazing. It will be a travesty if he doesn't win. Treyc - No wow factor for me. Good voice but leaves me cold. 1 Direction - I thought they were good. But it wasn't my favourite performance from them. Best - Matt, Aiden and Rebecca Bottom 2 Treyc and Katie. Katie to go. (I am in agreement with you this week Joyce)
|
|
|
Post by kim on Nov 7, 2010 21:00:52 GMT
What an absolute complete and utter farce. We've always said this show is fixed now I KNOW it is Dermot should have gone to Cheryl last which would have taken it to deadlock - but instead all rules went out of the window because you can bet your life Katie Weasel had the least votes Every week the judges say they base their decision on the sing off and Katie was absolute rubbish - why on earth are they keeping her in?
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Nov 7, 2010 21:29:55 GMT
It's a P*ss take Kim that she survives again. I couldn't get over Simon saying he was voting for the person he thinks the viewers want to see again next week ie Katie?? Err she has been in the bottom 2 three times now, is the message not getting across to Simon. What he means is he likes her, and to hell with what we think. She messed up her song AGAIN, and yet stays. Louis was just as bad. I smell a huge rat. On a positive note, it was great to see Shayne back.
|
|
|
Post by Dee on Nov 7, 2010 22:11:55 GMT
I was kind of glad with the decision I bet you are right Kim, with the deadlock situation but if I'm honest as good as a singer TrayC is, I would rather see Katy perform. TrayC had a great voice but Katy has a more interesting one, personal preference I suppose. Either way Katie won't be here much longer, she doesn't have the support. Mind you, next week Wagner will probably be in the bottom 2 and she'll be saved again. As long as my faves were ok I wasn't really bothered, would've preferred to have seen Mary in the bottom 2 instead of Trayc though. I was surprised she was in the bottom 2 as she had quite a good spot (meaning 3rd from last on)
|
|
|
Post by kim on Nov 7, 2010 22:42:46 GMT
Don't think Wagner is going anywhere at the moment Dee - there's a campaign to keep him in, similar to last year's Rage Against the Machine and it's gathered an awful lot more support after tonight's farce.
|
|
|
Post by joyce on Nov 8, 2010 0:32:46 GMT
Well b****y disgusted I was not bothered which one went I think they were both on borowed time, but it was the way it was done Katie totaly fell apart tonight and on that performance should have been voted off...Danii is the only one with any B***s Failing that It should have gone to deadlock, Cheryl is there to do a job which she failed badly tonight. I dont know what the hell is happening between her and Simon but she is sure pulling the strings this year. Watching xtra Factor Simon was asked who he thinks should win...He said based on last nights performance Rebecca, saying that after giving Matt the only standing ovation of the series so far I agree Caz, there is a bad smell this year more so than any other. Lol Dee, Kim's right Wagner's time is not up yet, There is one more to go before the tour group of 8, they want Wagner on the tour who will be sacrifised next as after tonight I think they want Katie too.. I would also think Mary also for the wider audience (no pun intended lol) I only hope it's not Paige that is the fall guy in this... xxx O forgot to mention Shayne yeh great to see him again, he looked well fit
|
|
|
Post by Dee on Nov 8, 2010 10:22:28 GMT
LOL, I did wonder why he had lasted so long!!! ;D I didn't watch Xtra Factor but I can't believe Simon said that I just don't think he has any credibility at all any more and take what he says with a pinch of salt. Statistically wise Matt will win as boys/men always do better out of these competitions, women don''t do so good. I only think Leona won because the competition wasn't that strong. Had she been up against the likes of Shayne Ward/Matt Cardell, it would've been a completely different story. Going back to Shayne, yep it was nice to see him and he looked good, thought he had a little too much facial hair for my liking though
|
|