|
Post by kim on Nov 14, 2010 21:01:06 GMT
What a joke - Simon Cowell has lost whatever speck of credibility he had. I knew as soon as it went to deadlock Aiden was out Still, one good thing - the crap song and curse of the first spot didn't work and Paije is still there ;D
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Nov 14, 2010 21:31:01 GMT
I am so angry. I cannot believe Simon had the audacity to save Katie again after last weeks farce. No way should Aiden have gone home against her. The programme is a joke. What hold has Cheryl got over Simon?? In the past never in this world would he have saved someone who had been in the bottom 2 four times. There is only one explanation for me and that is that he and Cheryl are at it. Poor Aiden. He won't even get on the tour either.
|
|
|
Post by joyce on Nov 14, 2010 23:13:09 GMT
Totally gutted for Aiden, If there is a shred of decency in Simon Cowell he will bend the rules and let Aiden on the tour, it may go a little way to make up for his lack of b***s to save him tonight. Two years running Simon has called it wrong last year with Lucie v Jedward, and this year with Aiden.
|
|
|
Post by joyce on Nov 15, 2010 1:19:35 GMT
|
|
|
Post by Dee on Nov 15, 2010 11:40:03 GMT
LOL, funny Joyce, if only ;D I really can't believe that Simon voted for Katie yet again, I agree Caz, there seems to be some ulterior motive, either he's at it with Cheryl or Katie I felt so sorry for Aiden, he wasn't very good in the sing off but he does seem to have trouble with nerves, on the other hand Katie has skin like a Rhino and being in the bottom is like water off a ducks back, eiter that or she knows she's not going anywhere
|
|
|
Post by kim on Nov 15, 2010 12:46:37 GMT
Lol Joyce ;D
|
|
|
Post by joyce on Nov 19, 2010 10:55:18 GMT
Totally gutted for Aiden, If there is a shred of decency in Simon Cowell he will bend the rules and let Aiden on the tour, it may go a little way to make up for his lack of b***s to save him tonight. Two years running Simon has called it wrong last year with Lucie v Jedward, and this year with Aiden. Yeh got my wish ;D
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Nov 19, 2010 16:40:45 GMT
I am really pleased Aiden will be on the tour now. They have obviously just realised how popular he was. This is the first time they have changed it from 8 to 9 isn't it? I am glad that he will be able to make some money now from the show as he has a great voice. There would be only 3 acts that I would be looking forward to seeing if I went to the tour and that would be Aiden, Matt and 1 Direction. Totally gutted for Aiden, If there is a shred of decency in Simon Cowell he will bend the rules and let Aiden on the tour, it may go a little way to make up for his lack of b***s to save him tonight. Two years running Simon has called it wrong last year with Lucie v Jedward, and this year with Aiden. Yeh got my wish ;D
|
|
|
Post by joyce on Nov 19, 2010 19:50:39 GMT
Yes Caz The only time there has been 9, is when there was only 3 judges, since the 4th judge 8
|
|
|
Post by Dee on Nov 21, 2010 0:52:06 GMT
Here's my take on tonights show: Matt - Wasn't keen on the weird put on voice but thought he finished quite stongly. Cher - That didn't work for me at all, yes it was in tune but too any squeaky bits One Direction - Very good but tbh this should have been their strongest week. Rebecca - Oh dear, this was really bad in places, she was definately very nervous and her worst performance yet. Mary - As much as I don;t like her, it was a good, strong performance. Wagner - Same old, felt for him tonight though, he definately put chav Cheryl in her place and I fear he will be safe for another week. Paige - Really good, enjoyed it. Katie - I might get berated for this but going on vocals I think she was the best of the night. I didn't particularly like her new look though Best of the night - Paige & Katie Worst - (not including Wagner) Rebecca & Cher Bottom 2 - Katie & Paige(going by fanbase but I hope not the case) Katie will go ( yeah right!)
|
|
|
Post by joyce on Nov 21, 2010 10:56:05 GMT
Matt, not his best week, but I can imagine him with a guitar and his band rocking that one out. Cher, I like her better when she has a full production and a bit rap 1D, I cant help but love these kids, they are so eager to please...they fetch out all my maternal instincts lol I like Paige, and think he was ok tonight Rebecca, was way off tonight Mary, for me best of the night, and I hate that version of the song Wagner, Well Cheryl has poss kept him in a bit longer with that rant. Katie, deff her best to date, Simon bigging her up will poss send her bottom 2 Cheryl was bang out of order, we are constantly been told to ignore/dot believe the press rubbish (Re Cheryl/Peirce Morgan interview)She should take her own advice , Wagner certainly won that one...Brought back the Sharon/Steve moment..She is there to judge not do a public assassination of someone!! Bottom 2 Katie, Paige And They deff not the worst
|
|
|
Post by kim on Nov 21, 2010 11:00:38 GMT
Thought last night's show was one of the poorest. I'm getting fed up with the judges bickering - the show is about the performers, not them. Also getting really peed off with the audience noise. I couldn't hear half of the judges comments and neither could the performers - what is the point?? This is what I thought: Matt - I enjoyed it, not one of his best though. Thought his styling was awful. Cher - Didn't like it at all, thought she sounded very pitchy in parts - no a patch on the last time she sang without rapping One Direction - Thought they were ok, but they are not really doing anything different from week to week Rebecca - Awful, definitely her weakest week - she could be in trouble Mary - Absolutely nothing to say - she still sounds like a pub singer and is completely irrelevant. I'll be glad when she goes Wagner - Getting bored with him now - it's time to leave - I'm hoping the anti XF voters get fed up and stop voting for him Paije - Performance of the night for me, why has Danni been giving still upbeat numbers when he sings ballads so well?? Katie - Notice she got the pimp spot yet again I disagree with you Dee, she spoke three quarters of the song - she was in tune at the end, but she needs to go. Didn't think much of her 'makeover'. Don't know if anyone saw Xtra Factor - one of the callers wanted to know why the judges kept saving her when she was obviously so unpopular with the public - Louis got really irate - there is definitely some sort of agenda going on with Katie. (I had to laugh, one of the headlines today is Katie's 81 year old gran is a hooker - I thought, they're going too far now making up stories that are just too ridiculous - but it was true ;D) Best of the night: Paije by a mile, then Matt and One Direction Prediction - Katie and Wagner bottom two - Wagner will be out.
|
|
|
Post by Dee on Nov 21, 2010 11:31:39 GMT
Well tbh Kim she was on last and I had, had a fair few red wines by then, maybe I'll have to watch it back Maybe we will get the truth one day but it's the unfairness of it all that makes her so unpopular. People don't like to think there is favouritism going on.
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Nov 21, 2010 13:01:10 GMT
lol Stay off that red wine Dee. I am pretty much in agreement with you this week Kim. I hope we never have another Beatles week as last nights show was dire. Matt - Good performance but not my fav performance of his. Cher - Didn't like the change of arrangement at all. Half way through it I was thinking Is she still singing Imagine?? Just ok for me. One Direction - Again they were good, but not my favourite performance of theirs either. Rebecca - Normally she is great, but it just didn't work for her last night. She said she is not used to walking and singing at the same time. God help her if she wins. She might even have to dance as well. ;D Mary - Another strong performance I thought. Probably the best of the night. Paije - Definitely one of his best performances to date. Wagner - I think now he is on the tour he won't last much longer tbh. Glad he put Cheryl in her place though. Katie - I was so angry that she got the pimp spot again. I don't know how they can justify putting her on last again, when I am sure there are still acts in the comp that still haven't been on last, and yet she gets it again. They want to guarantee her survival that's why. No one who ever goes on last is bottom 2. So I don't think she will be going anywhere tonight. Hope I am wrong as she should have gone weeks ago. Don't like the hair. It just emphasises her chin and ears even more. lol Kim that caller on xtra factor was spot on about Katie. But get Louis being her biggest fan all of a sudden. I couldn't get over all the praise he was giving her. That lady spoke for the majority of the British public, but because Katie comes to Louis dressing room she must be alright. I think Katie and Wagner SHOULD be bottom 2, but then Katie would survive yet again. But I think Rebecca or Paije may be bottom.
|
|
|
Post by kim on Nov 21, 2010 15:00:43 GMT
Well tbh Kim she was on last and I had, had a fair few red wines by then, maybe I'll have to watch it back Celebrating your birthday a week early?? ;D When I'm pissed I think everyone can sing - including me
|
|