|
Post by Dee on Oct 16, 2011 20:33:59 GMT
Well I have only just watched it as we were at a wedding yesterday, I agreed with most of what you said Kim, in fact, I could've wrote it!!lol I didn't hear the audience boo Kitty, Caz, when was it? I do think Frankie is being stitched up a bit too and hope he gets a better song next week as I quite like him. I think the right ones went tbh
|
|
|
Post by kim on Oct 16, 2011 21:37:01 GMT
Blimey, leaving poor Marcus until the last three was a bit scary His little face looked so upset Glad he went through in the end ;D The right acts were in the bottom two. Both of their sing offs were bad and either could have gone TBH. My theory of why they saved Frankie is the announcer bloke likes saying 'FRANKIE COCOZZAAAAAAAAHHHH!!!' He won't last (Frankie, not the announcer), I reckon they'll save him for another couple of weeks then he'll be gone 'cos he really is rubbish ;D The audience did boo Kitty on Saturday and there were boos when she went through tonight - not very nice at all
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Oct 16, 2011 22:49:55 GMT
My heart was in my mouth when Marcus was left right until the end. So glad he and the Risk were safe. Well done Kim you got the bottom 2 and the leaving act spot on. Top of the class for you. I would have liked to have seen more from Nu vibe, as I did think they had more to give, where as Frankie seemed quite weak again in his survival song, but definitely the curse of going on first for Nu vibe. I actually think they may have polled the lowest votes as well because of this, and where were all Frankie's fans tonight? According to the papers he and THe Risk are the most popular with the girls.
|
|
|
Post by joyce on Oct 22, 2011 1:04:53 GMT
Finally caught up with last week Agree with what you all thought, The Risk are real good did not agree with NV going l thought they sounded good, Frankie deff should have gone, and still cant see what they are seeing in Sophie they would have been my bottom two. I love Johnny ;D he is fun and can sing hope he is there till the end, infact I hope he wins serve them right for not giving the public the vote on the first live show..Amelia should deff not have gone for me she was one of the strongest contenders Could we be seeing the last year of xfactor UK
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Oct 22, 2011 10:09:23 GMT
I think it may well be the last Joyce. Especially now they are talking about the viewing figures going down. No doubt it will be because "the nations sweatheart" is no longer on the panel. For me the ratings should go up, as the judges are so much better this year, so not missing her or Simon one bit. *Joyce we left you a message in the topic Hero Dog*. Apparently now Craig has "come out" he is the fav to go tomorrow, as according to the Daily Star, these odds have only gone this way since admitting he is gay. Now come on, he was never going to be a pin up on any girls wall now was he?, so I fail to see how him coming out has now made him a fav to go. His voters are voting on his voice/performance/personality nothing else. Simples.
|
|
|
Post by joyce on Oct 22, 2011 23:33:29 GMT
What they should do is go back to the Pop Idol format no mentoring I think it was much better, no age group all compete together, I loved this and American Idol also. Xfactor USA will probably go the same way as our Xfactor Also for the groups have a different show to put together groups as they did with Girls Aloud,and Hearsay, and could even have all ready established groups enter too, tonights show was the worst ever car crash TV
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Oct 23, 2011 11:52:38 GMT
Yes Joyce I agree, Pop Idol was great - Sam Nixon, Gareth Gates etc. I used to love watching the Pop Idol shows they had on daily when they would show all the contestants at the piano learning their songs.
Here is my take on last nights show. Marcus - Loved it. He sounded amazing, and just love his voice.
Janet - Good strong performance, but didn't enjoy it as much as last week.
Sami - Good, but not great. Thought Gary was a bit harsh with his comments. It was only 2 weeks earlier that he was saying if she didn't make Louis category he would quit. Why does he now find her boring?
Rhythmix - Good performance. They are not getting worse, but didn't wow me either.
Sophie - Thought she sang really well last night. Much better vocals than previous week.
Craig - Another good performance from him.
Kitty - She does have a very good voice, and sang well. Difference between her and Katie Waissel is Kitty can sing, but don't think she could ever win the public over entirely.
Frankie - Looks like he is on something. Good performance, but I agree he doesn't seem to be taking the comp seriously, and seems to be more interested in the notches on his bedpost than doing well in the competition.
The Risk - Another very good performance from them I thought.
Johnny - I thought he was great, and really enjoyed his perfromance. I am converted. ;D
Micha B - Amazing performance, and well done to Tulisa for bringing up the fact that she is bullying other contestants. The public do have a right to know what kind of person she is, on and off the screen, if they are to spend money voting for her.
Tough one this week, I have no idea who I think bottom 2 will be, but I shall go with Sami, and Rhythmix or Frankie
|
|
|
Post by joyce on Oct 23, 2011 17:50:14 GMT
Here goes Marcus - love this guy he was great last night he has so much charisma. Janet -Enjoyed her performance but agree Caz not as good as last week Sami - Ok but cant see her in the final 3 Rhythmix - Good performance. but don't do much for me Sophie - good singer but unforgettable. Craig -good singer but not my type of artist. Kitty -I enjoyed her performance . Frankie - as I said on FB he came across like a spoilt kid very arrogant and acting like he deserved to be there rather than earning his place The Risk - not as good as last week but they are good Johnny - Glad your converted Caz...He makes me smile he sounds a real genuine guy ..his one liners are fantastic..would love him to do Queen..I want to Break Free..dressed as Freddie was Micha B - Easy the best but cant warm to her she should walk this competition if her off stage antics (if true) don't get in the way Bottom 2 for me Rhythmix and Frankie
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Oct 23, 2011 20:47:00 GMT
I actually preferred Kitty's performance on Saturday to Sami's, although tonight I preferred Sami's survival song. But I knew Louis wouldn't save Sami, as he didn't even choose her initially for his final 4, so that came as no surprise, but as their mentor, he should have let the public decide, as Kitty sang really well last night, but the public are not warming to her, so she has little chance of winning anyway.
|
|
|
Post by joyce on Oct 23, 2011 23:24:46 GMT
I think the judges should have no say full stop..lowest vote goes.. I liked Sammi for her personality and thought Kitty the better singer and as it is fast becoming about anything but singing cant say whether the right one went
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Oct 24, 2011 10:17:25 GMT
According to a This Morning poll, Joyce, 80% of the public said that Louis should have taken it to deadlock last night, so a lot of people not very happy with the way he went about things. If the public pay their money, then they should get final decision. Look at the hypocrisy with Katie Waissel last year. She was in the bottom 4 times, and the judges kept saving her, when the public didn't want her there, so how dare they go against everything the paying public wanted?
|
|
|
Post by Dee on Oct 25, 2011 22:46:06 GMT
Yeah, ultimately the public should decide, it's pointless going to the judges vote and totally obvious that their favourite didn't get the public vote if they don't take it to deadlock. I'm not complaining this time as I'm glad Kitty didn't go but I have many times before
|
|
|
Post by kim on Oct 28, 2011 19:25:32 GMT
OMG tomorrow's show is going to be interesting to say the least!
1. Kelly Rowland flew back to the States earlier in the week and won't be on the show this week because she has a sore throat (likely story!). Twitter rumours are that Nicole Shertzinger will be replacing her this week. My theory is that all this was planned, either Cheryl is coming back for the rest of the series, or Simon will be back just for Sunday's results.
2. Ashley from The Risk has left the group, rumours are he's got glandular fever and is being replaced by a member of NuVibe
3. Rhythmix are now called Little Mix - what a rubbish name!
The dramas outside of the show are getting more entertaining than the actual show ;D
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Oct 29, 2011 10:16:30 GMT
Ooh thanks for that Kim. Please god, NO CHERYL, do not want her back. I wonder if The Risk were having rows, as Ashley had throat problems last week, so surely the others could have shared the vocals until he was better, although never had Glandular fever so don't know how long it takes to recover, but interesting stuff.
|
|
|
Post by kim on Oct 29, 2011 13:54:43 GMT
The Daily Mail reckon Ashley didn't want to be in a boyband, he couldn't commit his future to them as he wants to be a solo artist. Ashford (the 16 year old black guy with the amazing eyes) is joining The Risk. (the glandular fever rumours were just rumours)
Alex Burke is guest judging tonight - that's got to be better than Cheryl ;D
|
|