|
Post by caz2 on Oct 28, 2013 10:20:28 GMT
I was shocked to see Hannah in the bottom 2 last night, and even more shocked that Abi wasn't. Who is seriously voting for her? When the acts sang together at the beginning of yesterdays show, I was in the hallway and said omg who is singing that bit. It was awful, and low and behold it was Abi. When it was down to Sam and Hannah for the bottom 2, I was worried that it may have been Sam, but only because he got negative comments saturday, so was also pleased when Hannah's name was announced. ;D I don't think it's that people thought she was safe, but more that she isn't that likeable, and as you said Kim dead behind the eyes. We haven't seen any real personality from her yet, so unless the public can warm to her, she may well find herself in the bottom again. Miss Dynamix were definitely the right act to go though.
|
|
|
Post by kim on Oct 28, 2013 13:21:19 GMT
It was a shock Hannah was bottom, but I was glad Sam was safe and it was guaranteed Miss Dynamix were out ;D I actually thought they were better in the sing off, Hannah sounded awful, her voice is too deep for me and her diction is not good. Simon Cowell actually tweeted the wrong act was saved I think she'll be safe next week but I don't fancy her chances of getting much further.
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Oct 28, 2013 17:28:11 GMT
Hannah has a really deep voice doesn't she? Maybe that is what doesn't appeal to the masses. Miss Dynamix sounded quite good in the sing off, but they weren't consistent. I heard that Simon had made that comment, but knowing Simon, he probably has his eye on the pretty South African girl, as opposed to them actually being better. We know how he likes to surround himself with a harem of olive/dark skinned women who more often that not bare huge similarities to each other. I think he has them cloned. ;D
|
|
|
Post by kim on Oct 28, 2013 17:56:50 GMT
So Cynical Caz ;D
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Nov 3, 2013 13:15:04 GMT
Here's my take on last nights acts. Luke - Thought he sang really well. Loved his performance. He really is the dark horse. Kingsland Road - I don't like the song but I thought they sang well. Tamera - A good performance but I wasn't blown away. Ballads suit her voice better. Sam C - He sounded like he had a cold and sang much better last week. Shame as I do like him. But it wasn't great. Rough Copy - I thought they sang better than last week, but I do find myself comparing them to JLS and tbh Rough Copy are not a patch on them. Awful clothes they wear as well. Abi - She sounds like a 5 year old when she sings. She did sound better when she went up a gear but not good enough. An improvement on last week though.......Just Nicholas - A great performance from him again. Hannah - Her voice got even deeper last night. ;D She sang well but how obvious that she has been told to be happy Hannah and smile more. She was like a cheshire cat last night. Sam B - She never has a bad performance. I couldn't fault it. Bottom 2 for me - Abi and Sam C and they will get rid of Sam. I am glad they have got rid of the Flash Vote, but not very fair to those in previous weeks who have found themselves bottom. Its a good job those who have gone were not great anyway, otherwise it really would be unfair that they have now just dramatically dropped it.
|
|
|
Post by kim on Nov 3, 2013 18:46:08 GMT
Was out last night so I've only just caught up - here's my (hungover ) take Luke - Was a bit concerned when I saw what he was singing, but thought he was excellent KR - Don't understand the judges criticism, thought they were good Tamera - I love that song and thought she did it justice Sam C - Oh dear, not good at all, awful song in the first place. Rough Copy - A bit more up to date - but not much and they look like fools! One of them sounds off key every week, but the little ones enthusiasm is so funny Abi - Not really disco was it? She was better than last week, but still not good Nicholas - I thought he struggled at the beginning, his lower range isn't perfect, rest of song was good Hannah - Still far too shouty, there's no light and shade with her Sam B - Note perfect but she just does not have the X FActor - very karoke/cruise ship. Loved Chic at the beginning and glad they ditched the flash vote (I spent 45 minutes on the journey home last night with crappy 3G trying to find out who'd lost the flash vote, only to discover they'd binned it ) Agree with you Caz I think Sam C and Abi will be bottom tonight, Sam C will go, but I wouldn't be surprised to see Hannah there again.
|
|
|
Post by Dee on Nov 3, 2013 22:34:55 GMT
Hi girls, I am still watching but had forgotten about this forum, my bad I was just thinking about what ppl thought of tonights results when I had thought of here and wondered if anyone had posted. I have just had 10 mins smiling at your posts! I am in almost complete agreement with you both. I didm;t like Luke at first and wondered why Louis chose him but he is fast becoming my favourite, I still can't stand his hair though I thought kings land road did not deserve to go but I think they are too much in the way of competition for one direction. I thought Rough Copy were quite good last night but seemed to have loads of backing vocals, I don;t think they harmonise well at all and have been shite the last couple of weeks despite what the judges say Tamira seems to have the whole package but I agree, she is another Leona, there is just no X Factor for me. Nicholas is cute and a brilliant singer but like you say, who will buy his album? I think the other lad Sam is on borrowed time, I didn't rate him in the first place. Sam Bailey just gets on my nerves, she's too ordinary, great voice but not enough to make up for her mumsy, boring appearance. Hannah, I really like her voice but she comes across as a bit sulky, she was obviously told this week, and yes she does look a bit a dead behind the eyes! ;D Abi, I like Abi and I like her voice but this is not the show for her.
|
|
|
Post by kim on Nov 4, 2013 13:11:35 GMT
Thought you wasn't our friend any more Dee Huge shock that Tamera was in bottom two, the voting is just weird this year. I don't think Gary is helping by keep slating Sam C, he did the same with Rylan last year and look how long he lasted ;D Getting more and more fed up with this series, it seems to be more about the judges than the acts. Sam B is going to win this and what an utter waste of time that will be
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Nov 4, 2013 16:47:11 GMT
Hi Dee. You forgot about your own forum? ;D Nice to see you, to see you........ Oh wrong show. Well we were spot on with our predictions for bottom 2 then Kim. Didn't see that one coming. I am pleased Sam C wasn't bottom, but I am sorry Dee (cover your ears) who is voting for Abi?? It might have been a bit of a wake up call for Tamera her being bottom 2, as I think she thought it was hers to lose, as she was bookies fav, although don't know whether that was still the case, and yes she has a great voice, but she does seem to excel more when doing ballads. I am thinking Sam B will win as well Kim unfortunately. Although I am sure Nicholas and even Luke will give her a good run for her money.
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Nov 10, 2013 13:20:45 GMT
Here is my take on last nights acts. Abi - A good performance for her I thought. It has taken 5 weeks for it to happen but better late than never. I think the big band drowning out her voice also helped. ;D Sam B - Another really good performance from her. Nicholas - A really good performance again from him. He is always consistent. Although I wonder if he is 16 by any chance? How many times do the judges have to keep mentioning the fact that he is only 16?? They don't do it with Tamera. Luke - I enjoyed his performance. I thought he sang so well, and totally disagree with Gary and Nicole's comments. Hannah - Her voice is way too deep for my liking, and she has got so annoying. Plus This is a mans world has been done to death on this programme. Rough Copy - Thought they gave a really good performance, and their best to date. Tamera - The song suited her voice so well. I doubt she will be bottom 2 this week. Sam C - I thought his performance was a massive improvement on last weeks and he gave a good performance, although why Gary gave such little feedback shows that he still thinks very little of him and his performance. The bottom 2 for me would be Abi and Hannah. Although considering Abi has never been bottom 2, not sure whether this will be the case tonight, but we can live in hope. Out of the 2 of them don't care who goes, but it is more likely to be Abi.
|
|
|
Post by kim on Nov 10, 2013 17:36:02 GMT
Got really bored with last night's show - I'm not a fan of big band Abi - Very shaky start, but she did ok, she just seems to have lost her oomph though Sam B - Still can't see her as a star, so old fashioned - sings well, but so do thousands of others. I just don't get the hype Nicholas - Note perfect, but yes its very annoying keep being told he's 16 - so what? Luke - Agree with you Caz, I thought he sang really well Hannah - Cannot stand her voice, her diction is awful, it's just a load of deep mumbled shouting, plus I hate that song AND she played the dead dad card Rough Copy - Performance of the night for me, think they are being groomed to be the new JLS Tamera - She seems to have lost her sparkle too. Still think her voice is the best in the competition though Sam C - Thought he was ok, he's not the best singer granted, but he is likeable. Bottom two same as you Caz - Abi will go. Won't be able to watch next week's until later in the week, my son gets married on Saturday and I don't think watching XF will go down well in the middle of the reception ;D
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Nov 10, 2013 21:34:36 GMT
Wow we were spot on tonight Kim, and thank god Abi went. I don't know if I was listening to something completely different to Gary but I thought her sing off song was awful. He is really starting to annoy me the way he keeps saying that the wrong acts were in the bottom two, him obviously annoyed that Sam C survives again. I might even vote for him myself after that. Aww so your son gets married next week then Kim. Yes I think that may not be very pc for the grooms mother to be more interested in whats going on, on tv. ;D Hope you all have a great day Kim.
|
|
|
Post by kim on Nov 11, 2013 11:54:47 GMT
Yep, we're getting good at this Thought both sing offs were awful, but actually preferred Abi's, just do not like Hannah's voice - it sounds like drone, drone, drone, shout, drone, drone, drone, shout to me I think the judges must be hearing something different to us when they said the wrong two were in the bottom Gary is so bitter about Sam C ;D ;D
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Nov 17, 2013 12:43:46 GMT
Here's my take on last nights show. Hope you had a great day at your sons wedding Kim. Hannah - She sounded okay. Her voice really is like marmite, and does nothing for me. Luke - Loved his performance and thought he sang really well. Sam B- Nailed it as usual. She does have a great voice, but would the same people who vote for her every week, go out and buy her music? Not so sure. Rough Copy - Didn't like this performance as much as last week's. For me these guys are not consistent enough. One minute they are great and the next week not so great (unlike Jls, who were always great ) Sam C - Again okay not great, but he is likeable and really does get a hard time from Gary which is totally unnecessary. He keeps saying he is the weakest singer in the comp and even said that when Abi was still there I hope the public get behind him again, just to see the look on Garys face when his name is called out ;D Tamera - Her performance was good, even though she forgot the words (AGAIN) but for me she isn't the best singer in the comp, and she does seem to be slipping down week after week instead of getting better. Maybe she just needs to find her niche, but it is week 6, how late does she want to leave it? Nicholas - Performance of the night for me. Loved it. Bottom 2 - Now this is a tough one as it could be Hannah, Rough Copy, Tamera or even Sam C, but hoping its not the latter, so going for Hannah and Rough Copy with Hannah going.
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Nov 18, 2013 16:19:51 GMT
Did not think Luke deserved to be in the bottom 2 last night, and a shame that it had to be with Sam C, but I was happy that Luke stayed out of the 2, as he does have a great voice. I think Hannah will be in the bottom 2 this weekend and probably only avoided being in the bottom because Nicole said she was going to be voting lots for her. FIX Very surprised at seeing Miley Cyrus with clothes on last night, but bloody hell she sounded flat for the most part of that song. I think that's why she must wear so little, to take the attention away from those vocals. She missed a trick last night. ;D
|
|