|
Post by kim on Oct 21, 2012 21:15:18 GMT
Had in laws staying so not had time to write my thoughts on Saturdays show. Shocked Kye in bottom two he was one of my favourites. Glad he stayed though
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Oct 28, 2012 11:55:15 GMT
Here's my take on last nights acts. Kye - Fancy putting him on first when he was in the bottom 2 last week??? I thought he gave a good performance, although I thought he was amazing last Saturday and he was still in the bottom so who knows. Hope he is safe though. Union J - Great performance from them again I thought. Loved it. Rylan - Entertaining as always. Nothing more to say really. Ella - I thought she sounded amazing, and hit all those big notes. Chris - A good performance from him, and however cheesy we all find him, I did feel sorry for him again this week as Nicole's comments are just silly, never constructive and Tulisa was just damn right nasty. Loved Gary's comment about her f*g breath. Ooh if looks could kill. ;D District 3 - Aww it was just ok for me their performance this week. It sounded quite off key at times. But I do really like them so hope they're safe, and when they're on form, they're great. Jahmene - Such an amazing voice. Love this guy and his nervous little giggle. ;)Cannot fault him. He really does have a beautiful voice. Jade - Just an ok performance from her again I thought. Her performances always seem to have something missing. Think she may be in the bottom 2 tonight. James Arthur - Such emotion in his voice. Thought he gave another really strong performance. Bottom 2 - Jade and District 3 or Rylan Is anyone else finding Nicole really annoying, or is it just me? Her comments are always bordering on the ridiculous, and I think she turns everything into the Nicole show. Even Rylan's birthday ended up about her.
|
|
|
Post by kim on Oct 28, 2012 13:47:48 GMT
My take - didn't pay attention to all of it though!! Kye - Was dreading what he was going to sound like doing Robbie, but was impressed, he did a good job. Hopefully he'll get the bounce back vote and won't be bottom two again this week. Union J - one of the acts I wasn't watching carefully - what I heard sounded ok though Rylan - Thought it was his best week. But Gary giving positiveish comments could see him in the bottom two Ella - She's losing some of her sparkle for me. Excellent singer, but becoming very samey every week Chris - Do not like him or his singing. He is so out of place. I thought Gary was well out of order with Tulisa - most unprofessional District 3 - Sounded bad, too many bum notes. Think they could be in trouble Jahmene - Performance of the night for me. I much prefer his voice without the 'yelping' Jade - Good voice and performance, but there was something missing - she could be bottom two James - Not my music choice at all, but he was very good. All that make up he had on looked daft though! Who I'd like bottom two - Chris and District 3 with Chris out Who I think bottom two - Jade and District 3 with District 3 out
|
|
|
Post by kim on Oct 28, 2012 21:21:01 GMT
Shocker about Union J No big surprise about Jade though. I've liked her from the start, but she's definitely got worse as the weeks have gone by. So pleased for Kye, but at this rate I can see that orange Christopher winning Very strange series
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Oct 28, 2012 21:41:19 GMT
I was shocked about Union J as well Kim as I thought they sang really well last night, but also pleased for Kye. Jade sang her save me song really well, but I agree, she has been gradually getting worse week by week, so on the whole, I was very pleased Union J survived. I thought Chris sang well last night, although he does not have the x factor, but Tulisa's nasty comments about him destroying another song wasn't necessary, and ultimately he is gaining more votes because of this. As soon as all the judges say they loved his performance, he will go. ;D
|
|
|
Post by Dee on Oct 29, 2012 13:51:49 GMT
Hi girls:) Sorry I didn't comment last week, we went out and didn't see it til later. We had friends round sat night and didn't watch til last night (with a major hangover) Here are my thoughts but I obviously know the result:) Kye - I thought he sang it really well but I did think he was copying Robbie's mannerisms. I still think there is something missing for me Union J - Thought they were great, enjoyed their performance. Rylan - Not great vocals but he makes up for it in entertainment:) Ella - I agree Kim, she is getting very samey, still fab voice though. Chris - OMG how is this guy still in??? I just don't get it. I'd rather watch Rylan than him ;D District 3 - I actually enjoyed their performance Maybe it was the hangover affecting me ;D Jahmene - Great voice but he has the Leona effect on me. Fab voice but no X Factor Jade - She just doesn't look like a professional, everything seemed scripted, she was acting out the steps but she wasn't dancing, her voice really lacks something too, it's a shame because I really liked her in the beginning. James - Over the past two weeks he has definately become my favourite He delivers every time. Who I'd like bottom two - Chris and Jade with Chris out I'm not surprised Jade has gone, I kind of agreed with Gary that they seem to want it more than her. I didn't see Garys comment to Tulisa as we FF it. Caz I definately agree with you re Nicole, she is really getting on my nerves, what is she on??? She's coming across divaish and now Simon has gone is trying to make it all about her, its not endearing at all
|
|
|
Post by joyce on Oct 29, 2012 18:05:27 GMT
So Gutted Jade has gone This for me is the worst xfactor ever I honestly cant understand why I am still watching it ;D My take Kye - He done ok was one of his better weeks….but that’s not hard ;D Union J – enjoyed their performance…but do we want another 0ne Direction Rylan - Entertaining maybe this is why I am watching to see what he does…next week he is doing a straight song….guess they think his time is up Que Gay liking him..that was any artists kiss of death with Simon Ella great vocals but agree she has no xfactor for me Chris He sings ok but he is so boring…wonder when he is gona sing Youll Nevr Walk Alone…or will that be his save me song District 3 – Real bad on the night and should have been bottom 2 Jahmene – Really warming to this lad no doubt he has a great voice and I just want to give him a cuddle ;D Jade – Wrong song and think she has been stitched up badly, and on that performance deff bottom 2 James Arthur –love the way he changes the songs and think he is very talented …but creepy and still cant warm to his personality. or lack of ;D I would have had Bottom 2 - Jade and District 3 As I said gutted Jade has gone...for me I think she had it all yeah not the best vocals but this lass had never up to her audition sang in front of anyone..She was so gracious in defeat too ..Tulisa has to take some blame for wrong song choices and in the sing off she deff out sang the lads Last week she was poorly but sang and only started rehearsing late this week ..while Lucie gets a bye into next week.. Maybe she should have started shaking and crying in the sing off it may have just saved her ha ha ;D
|
|
|
Post by joyce on Oct 29, 2012 18:15:16 GMT
Just to add Nicole is doing me head in its all me me me, Thought Gary was way out of order with Tulisa, but to be honest think its all staged the have to make this year something to get ppl talking as it is failing fast...Top 3 has to be Ella,James and Jahmene...now that will probs be the kiss of death lol
|
|
|
Post by joyce on Oct 29, 2012 19:15:13 GMT
|
|
|
Post by kim on Oct 30, 2012 18:16:03 GMT
He did it a couple of weeks ago Joyce. Remember the dancing pandas? ;D
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Nov 3, 2012 11:04:34 GMT
Just heard that Lucy has decided to quit the x factor because she still isn't well enough to perform. Some say its flu, others say alcohol poisoning ie (Rylan) lol. Who knows and Tulisa only has the one act now. Shame as I did like Lucy, but don't think she would have ever won, and doubt we have seen the last of her.
|
|
|
Post by Dee on Nov 3, 2012 23:12:17 GMT
Aww sad about Lucy but I'm sure your right Caz, it's not the last we've seen of her. Ok, my take on tonights show:) Rylan - really enjoyed it, his vocals weren't that bad either and he just seems like a really nice guy. There are others I would rather see go before him. Kai - Good vocals and more entertaining on stage, I just don't see a star Union J - really enjoyed this and thought they were very good, one of my favourite performances. James Arthur - he is seriously growing on me, fantastic performance! Ella - agreed with Gary, the song was too high for her but I liked it:) District 3 - OMG terrible, especially the beginning, they were all over the place, too much dancing and not concentrating on vocals enough Jahmene - I really think I was 'listening' to a different song to the judges. I thought he really struggles with it, too many vocal acrobatics, again he just sounded all over the place, i didn't like it Chris - Bleugghhhh - I can't even watch him, her gets on my nerves that much! Who I think will be in bottom 2 - District 3 and Rylan Who I want in the bottom 2 - District 3 and Chris
|
|
|
Post by kim on Nov 4, 2012 10:48:58 GMT
Sorry to see Lucy go even though I wasn't a fan, I thought she was more suited to BGT. I reckon the illness story is a cover for something and there is more to her departure than meets the eye. Rylan - Thought his vocals were surprisingly good He's definitely the most entertaining. Really hope he stays tomorrow I look forward to seeing him Kye - I like Kye. I thought he did a good job this week Union J - Good performance and vocals. Hopefully the voters will take this into account and not vote for District 3 out of pity because of the judges comments. James Arthur - Disagree with you I'm afraid Dee. I thought his performance was a complete dog's dinner, he was all over the place. And the stupid rapping in the middle was cringeworthy. Shame as he had won me over the past couple of weeks Ella - Her worst performance. She seems to be going backwards District 3 - The only good thing was the backflip! How could Louis have got it so wrong? I think they may avoid the bottom 2 though, they have a huge twitter following - bigger than Union J who I think is the better group Jahmene - Disagree again Dee. I thought his performance was stunning. Agree he needs to tone down some of the vocal acrobatics, but finally Ella has a rival for top spot! Christopher - Bleuuuuugh indeed Dee. I cannot stand this bloke and his false tears, goodish karaoke at best. I can see him winning the show though - he'll disappear never to be seen again hopefully! Bottom two - Want Christopher and Christopher with Christopher going Think - Kye and District 3 - District 3 out I'm finding this series more and more difficult to watch, everything about it seems so scripted. I know it's always been contrived, but the judges comments this year are not honest. Ratings are really low too, I can see this or the next series being the last.
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Nov 4, 2012 13:04:22 GMT
Hi guys. Here is my take on last nights acts. Just watched it back as out last night. Rylan - Entertaining as always. I enjoyed his performance. Union J - Vocals were fab. Loved their performance. Kye - Good performance but no wow factor for me. James Arthur - Puts his all into it, as always. Makes you believe every word. Thought he sang really well. Ella - Another strong performance from her again I thought. Lovely voice. District 3 - Too much going on, and quite cheesy. Vocals were all over the place. I think Louis has let these lads down. His focus seems to be on Union J and seems to give all the better songs to them. Backflip was good though I agree Kim. Jahmene - Loved it, loved it, loved it. I just think he gets better week after week, and blows me away every time. Absolutely fabulous. My fav contestant by far. Chris - Think he may struggle tonight, as his vocals were a bit ropey. Other weeks he has sang much better. My bottom 2 - District 3 (unfortunately) and Chris Who I think will be in the bottom - Kye and Chris, with Chris going
|
|
|
Post by joyce on Nov 4, 2012 15:57:41 GMT
He did it a couple of weeks ago Joyce. Remember the dancing pandas? ;D Shows how much notice I am taking ;D
|
|