|
Post by joyce on Nov 4, 2012 16:18:35 GMT
I am with you Kim, and still wondering why I am sill watching this Rylan – Vote Rylan xfactor winner 2012 ;D Union J –possibly their best week. Kye –he was ok but agree no xfactor. James Arthur – thought he was all over the place too, but think he is the most marketable out of them all Ella – did not like her version of Firework at all District 3 – not getting these at all Jahmene – I love his voice think he has a great chance of winning..but I think he would be another failed male winner Chris – O dear who is voting for him My bottom 2 - District 3 and Chris
|
|
|
Post by kim on Nov 4, 2012 21:07:23 GMT
Only shocker about the bottom two is that District 3 wasn't in it! Glad Rylan stayed, was shocked by his singing. Sorry to see Kye go though. I'm off to have a bet on Christopher winning, He must have a huge fan base to still be there
|
|
|
Post by joyce on Nov 4, 2012 21:21:24 GMT
I am so pleased Rylan stayed but fear his time is near ...lol Kim Can we hope for a p** take final Rylan v Christopher l
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Nov 4, 2012 21:35:06 GMT
Not a happy bunny. Kye outsung Rylan in the sing off. Tulisa still pissed at Gary for the f*g ash breath comment. Why have a sing off if you're not basing your opinion on the better singer in the sing off, however entertaining Rylan is??? Chris to win ;D
|
|
|
Post by Dee on Nov 4, 2012 23:20:32 GMT
Aww Caz, I agreed with Tulisa, especially the comment about it's not just about the voice. I thought Rylan sang brilliantly even though I didn't know the song I was so glad that he stayed and tbh it went down to the public vote so Kai is obviously not as popular as Rylan. Kai sounded ok, but to me his voice isn't extra-ordinary and he didn't have anything about him, I would rather watch Rylan than Kai Joyce if there was a Rylan v Chris final I fear I would actually break my vow and vote again just to make sure Chris didn't win ;D
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Nov 5, 2012 0:24:42 GMT
I didn't rate Kai's performance saturday, as like I said, it had no wow factor, so I could understand him being in the bottom 2, but with the sing off, he blew Rylan out of the water and totally outsung him. So I think if he had been given a song like that, where he could give it some welly, I doubt he would have been in the bottom 2. You know as well as I do, that song choice is key, and one week you could be bottom 2 and next week you could be topping the polls, so for me I just think Tulisa went for the jugular to get at Gary for choosing to save Union J last week over Jade, and for the f*g ash comment, rather than doing the right thing, and fair play to Louis he did do the right thing and voted for the better singer. Ok rant over ;D
|
|
|
Post by kim on Nov 5, 2012 12:08:50 GMT
Haha Joyce, Rylan v Christopher final surely would be the final nail in the coffin for XF ;D Caz I like both Kye and Rylan, but I was glad Rylan was saved. The show is not what it used to be, but Rylan does at least offer some entertainment. Rylan does have the 'X Factor' Kye doesn't, even if his voice is better and that is the key to why he went. Not expecting Rylan to last for more than a couple of weeks now, but at least we have this Saturday's performance to look forward to ;D I've heard rumours Simon is thinking of having Sharon back on the panel next year - I would definitely not be watching if that is the case
|
|
|
Post by Dee on Nov 5, 2012 17:11:01 GMT
I dunno, I like to think Tulisa seems fair and if Gary didn't come out with smart, inappropriate comments then there would be no conspiracy theory. Besides, i still think it should go down to the public vote, not the judges. OMG Kim, if Sharon returns that will definately be the final nail in the coffin for me! I think Simon has started to lose his grip on what the public wants tbh, X Factor is naff now
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Nov 5, 2012 19:03:41 GMT
Kim you have got to be kidding me Rylan has the x factor? ;D Have you been on the sherry? He has the entertainment factor, but for me the x factor is about the Voice, the look, the whole package, and that is NOT Rylan. Don't get me wrong Rylan does entertain me, but for the wrong reasons. If any of the remaining great singers,- Jahmene, Ella, James or Union J, were in the bottom 2 with Rylan, and they kept Rylan over one of those acts, just because he makes good tv, it would take away everything the show should be about, and the show would lose even more credibility than it has already. As for Sharon, oh dear don't want to see her back. I will be turning off as well.
|
|
|
Post by joyce on Nov 10, 2012 22:06:58 GMT
My take on tonights show…. Think they all were better than last week Christopher – I really feel sorry for him he don’t deserve the nastiness he is getting from the judges – they put him there Jahmene – loved him would say he was my fav tonight District 3 – enjoyed their performance Ella – great vocal Rylan – Entertaining as ever…think his times up Union J – Thought they were fantastic tonight great song choice James – Brilliant but so bloody depressing Bottom 2 Christopher and Rylan …if this is the case I can see Rylan surviving another week
|
|
|
Post by Dee on Nov 10, 2012 23:26:54 GMT
Here's my thoughts on tonight:) I agree Joyce, it's gonna be tough to call it Christopher – Competent performance but he still doesn't do it for me, agree though Joyce, they put him there. Jahmene – much better this week without the vocal acrobatics. District 3 – Loved them this week, I thought their harmonies were bang on! Ella – Really good but she is coming across a bit predictable now Rylan – Loved it and laughed all the way through, I love him ;D Union J – Absolutely brilliant! The bands are extremely strong tonight! James – Didn't know the song but loved it:) Bottom 2, who I want - Christopher & Ella Bottom 2 who I think it will be - Christopher and Rylan, I hope Rylan survives again ;D
|
|
|
Post by kim on Nov 11, 2012 11:24:51 GMT
Christopher - What can I say that I haven't already said. The fact he's still there is just winding me up Only good thing I can say about his performance was he was on first so we got it over and done with quickly ;D Gary is losing more and more credibility every week, I also like the way he evades questions about Christopher's ability to sell records and become an international star. Jahmene - Didn't like it as much as last week, but still very good. The yelping was back He said last night he would like to sing a gospel song - why the hell don't they let him?? District 3 - much, much better. Louis should let them do what they are good at - harmonising (mind you I missed the back flip ) Ella - Amazing singer, but she's the same every week. Rumours in the press that she's just missed the bottom two in the voting the past couple of weeks - she may not be safe tonight Rylan - Yes Caz, for me he does have the X Factor. To me that means somebody who is charismatic and likeable. Granted his voice is not great, but since when has that stopped other 'stars' who sound awful live? I don't look on XF as a credible singing competition any more, it is purely for entertainment purposes only! There's not one act from this year whose music I would buy, but I would watch Rylan again and again (and if he released a good dance track, I might download it) Loved his performance last night, even if he did get caught up in his harness at the beginning and his jacket split ;D He's the only one I look forward to seeing, if he goes I won't be that bothered if I see the show or not. Union J - Very good. Don't know their names, but one of them is an exceptional singer. Don't think their harmonies were as good as District 3s though, but they are the better looking bunch James - Exceptional after really not liking him last week. I did know the Adele song, but it was unrecognisable. I also now know what dub step is - when my kids talk about dub step I just nod and pretend I know what they're talking about Just need to find out what double dub step is now! Daily Star, which have always been spot on with voting leaks have said Christopher is still topping the votes every week Jahmene is second, with the rest nowhere near - noooooooooooo!!!! (With IAC starting tonight, lets hope the Christopher voters decide to spend their money on bushtucker trials instead of XF) Who I want to be bottom two - Christopher and Christopher, Christopher out (I think Christopher is the only judges vote Rylan would win, he would go against anyone else) Who I think - Ella and Rylan - Rylan out (think even Nicole would vote him out)
|
|
|
Post by caz2 on Nov 11, 2012 13:20:09 GMT
Here is my take on last nights acts Chris - Thought he sang well, albeit a bit cheesy with the song choice. The week he sings I'm still standing will probably be the week he's booted out. Jahmene - Fanbloodytastic. There has not been one performance from him that I haven't liked. District 3 - Fab. Back to their best. Ella - Didn't like her performance as much this week. Thought she sounded shouty in parts and out of tune at times. Rylan - Vocals sounded worse than ever. Novelty has worn off for me. Kim we are going to have to agree to disagree about Rylan having the x factor as he is too much like Marmite to ever have the "X FACTOR". Fun factor yes Union J - Another great performance from them I thought. I do have a feeling that because both groups were great, that the vote may be split tonight. Really hope not as both groups were on form last night. James Arthur - Another really strong performance from him I thought. Don't think he's ever had a bad week, although I do agree with the depressing part Joyce. He never sings an upbeat happy song. Bottom 2 - Think it should be Rylan and Ella with Rylan going Think it will be Rylan and Union J but don't ask me which way Tulisa would go after last week.
|
|
|
Post by joyce on Nov 11, 2012 20:59:19 GMT
Well we were all wrong lol....so a Rylan v Christoper final is still on
|
|
|
Post by kim on Nov 11, 2012 21:32:38 GMT
Think you might be right Joyce Glad Union J were saved
|
|